You’ve got a leftover ham bone so let’s make some soup. There is nothing much more classic then ham and white bean soup. Use up that holiday ham bone with this traditional soup.
Editor’s Note: Originally Published December 13, 2014. This is one of the most popular recipes on the site, but it needed a buff-up with re-edited pictures and cleaned up text along with an expanded discussion of options. Please enjoy this wonderful soup.
This is my take on traditional Senate Bean Soup. It is a simple soup made with navy beans, ham hocks, and onion. It is always on the menu in the dining room of the United States Senate. There are two versions with one using mashed potatoes to thicken the soup.
I combined about five recipes and methods so no specific inspiration piece other than the Senate recipe. Most recipes use chicken broth for all or part of the liquid.
As pointed out to me by some commenters on Ham Bone Vegetable Soup – Crock Pot Edition cooking the ham bone like this is making your own ham broth. So chicken broth is not needed plus it saves on the sodium.
Some of the recipes suggested 8 hour cooking times on low even with non-soaked beans. It took the full 10 hours with the overnight soaked beans to be the right consistency.
Lastly, the amount of liquid varied from 6 cups to 12 cups. Many commenters thought the high end was just too much liquid. I suggest 6 cups. It did not completely cover the ham but was just right. They, like me, want a thicker bean soup.
Other Ham Bone Soup Options
Puerto Rican Chuletón Soup AKA Xmas Ham Bone Soup
Ham Bone Vegetable Soup – Crock Pot Edition
Pre-Week of Soup Recipes
Week of Soups Recipes
My Rating
A low five for us ham and bean soup lovers. A nice 4 for everybody else.
Pro Tips: Recipe notes on Crock Pot Ham Bone and Bean Soup
The Ham
The ham in the recipe is THE huge variable. Start with a “meaty” bone. If you stripped it, you would have no meat.
All hams have a huge amount of salt. Many of our hams have been covered with honey or other sweet products. Also, you have a large amount of fat, much of it on the surface.
All those things are a problem that could ruin your soup. So the preparation of the ham is critically important.
Use running water to remove surface sugar. Scrape off any fat that you can. And be careful with the sodium.
The Beans
This was a great recipe to start using dry beans. And if you’re on a budget, it makes this soup extremely cheap considering you were going to toss that ham bone.
Can I use precooked beans?
This recipe will be fine with precooked beans if you don’t want to go the dried bean route. The 1 pound of dry will equal approximately three cans or one 48 oz jar of precooked beans.
You should drain the beans and rinse them well to decrease any added salt. Of course, use low sodium products and cooking time will decrease a few hours.
Why Soak Dry Beans?
About soaking dry beans. It was always done in the “good old days.” A nice overnight soak was always done. Also, picking through the beans for pebbles and rocks was important. We frequent found them.
You will find recipes that don’t soak. There is also a “rapid soak” method that involves bringing them to a boil for a few minutes then allowing to rest for an hour (Check Epicurious.com).
So does soaking the dry beans do anything?
The no-soak crowd apparently think soaking is a waste of time. Tradition says less gas and more even cooking.
Well, our friends at Cooks Illustrated in The Science of Good Cooking have done some testing and find that there is less gas.
Let me explain. There are some simple carbohydrates in beans that humans can not digest. But your intestinal bacteria can digest them which produce a lot of gas.
Soaking decreases these carbohydrates some but the rapid method even more. But neither method comes anywhere close to eliminating them. Now, don’t you feel smarter?
A Final Note on Salt:
So just as a reminder if you didn’t read all the above, most hams have LOTS of salt. Don’t add any until you’re sure you need it.
A veggie note:
The carrot and celery are an option, but I thought made it more interesting.
A nice meaty ham bone and some simple ingredients are all that’s needed. Dry beans are in the picture but see the discussion above or the recipe card below for canned or jarred beans.
Rinse 1 pound of navy or great northern dry beans. Pick through the beans for any stones or pebbles. Cover with water and allow to soak overnight. See notes if using precooked beans.
Under running water rinse any coating off a meaty ham bone. Also, scrape off any surface fat that you can. Add to a larger crock pot.
Dice 2 medium carrots, two stalks celery, and one medium onion. Carrot and celery are options but recommended.
Add the drained beans, carrots, celery and onion to the crock pot. Add 1/2 teaspoon garlic powder, 1/2 teaspoon pepper, and one bay leaf. Add 6 cups water.
Cook on low for 10 hours total but at about 8 hours remove ham bone to a cutting board. Allow the bone to cool for 10-15 minutes. Then remove all meat from the bone. Discard bone and any fat and waste. Place meat back into the cooker and finish cooking. This is a good point to taste test for adding salt if needed. Note: Cooking time can be decreased a few hours if using precooked beans.
Do you want more recipes from 101 Cooking for Two? Sign up for the newsletter and get all posts delivered straight to your inbox!
Crock Pot Ham Bone and Bean Soup
Ingredients
- 1 pound dry navy beans - or great northern; see note about precooked beans
- 1 ham bone - meaty
- 2 carrots - medium - diced - optional
- 2 stalks celery - - diced - optional
- 1 onion - medium - diced
- 1/2 teaspoon garlic powder
- 1/2 teaspoon black pepper
- 1 bay leaf
Instructions
- Rinse 1 pound of navy or great northern dry beans. Pick through the beans for any stones or pebbles. Cover with water and allow to soak overnight. See notes if using precooked beans.
- Under running water rinse any coating off a meaty ham bone. Also, scrape off any surface fat that you can. Add to a larger crock pot.
- Dice 2 medium carrots, two stalks celery, and one medium onion. Carrot and celery are options but recommended.
- Add the drained beans, carrots, celery and onion to the crock pot. Add 1/2 teaspoon garlic powder, 1/2 teaspoon pepper, and one bay leaf. Add 6 cups water.
- Cook on low for 10 hours total but at about 8 hours remove ham bone to a cutting board. Allow the bone to cool for 10-15 minutes. Then remove all meat from the bone. Discard bone and any fat and waste. Place meat back into the cooker and finish cooking. This is a good point to taste test for adding salt if needed. Note: Cooking time can be decreased a few hours if using precooked beans.
Recipe Notes
Pro Tips:
- Hambones (and hams) vary a lot. So this is like many recipes... guidelines and not rules.
- If yours is honey coated or spiced heavily, you need to rinse as much of that off as possible.
- Salt note: Most hams have LOTS of salt. Don't add any until you're sure you need it and use low sodium products if possible.
- Can I use precooked beans?
This recipe will be fine with precooked beans if you don't want to go the dried bean route. The 1 pound of dry beans will equal approximately three cans or one 48 oz jar of precooked beans. You should drain and rinse the beans. Please use low sodium beans if possible. And the cooking time will decrease a few hours. - If you seem to have a fatty ham, cook then refrigerate to cool then skim the fat.
Have a question or something not clear? Ask in the comments.
Nutrition is for one serving. Number of servings is stated above and is my estimate of normal serving size for this recipe.
All nutritional information are estimates and may vary from your actual results. This is home cooking, and there are many variables. To taste ingredients such as salt will be my estimate of the average used.
If you like this recipe or find it useful, the pleasure of a nice 4 or 5 rating would be greatly appreciated.
Originally Published December 13, 2014
Nutrition is always somewhat of a guess, but the fat here is so variable. This is my best guess.
Related Posts:
Karen
I keep my recipe for this soup pretty simple. I prefer to use navy beans, don’t use chicken stock, carrots or celery. I use water, white onion and lots of ground black pepper with a meaty ham bone studded with whole cloves. This was my mother’s way of making it and I find it very tasty.
Trudy K Spicer
I like Navy beans and I use half chicken broth and water in my bean soup. It really gives the soup a great flavor
Sam
Try a bowl with a squirt of ketchup. Got that idea as kid from a neighbor who was a cook on a battleship in WWII.
DrDan
Hi Sam,
Welcome to the blog. Sorry for the delayed response, a bit of minor surgery.
I love old ideas like this. And it sounds tasty.
Thanks for the note.
Dan
Carol
In the crock pot now and thinking about adding spinach at the end of cooking time. Thoughts?
DrDan
Hi Carol,
Welcome to the blog.
I see the spinach as a more “delicate” taste. I think the ham might just over power it. But it won’t hurt to try.
Thanks for the note.
Dan
Carol
Thanks for the quick response. I tried a small handful in a sample bowl and just let the heat of the soup wilt it. Didn’t like the texture it added. I’ll leave well enough alone! Thanks for the great recipe.
Heather C
Super excited to have found this recipe! We make a ham along with turkey for Friendsgiving and I found your recipe yesterday – I appreciated the simplicity of it. I soaked the beans and let it sit all day in the crockpot. I used the immersion blender to make it a bit creamier – seriously the best soup ever. We are hot sauce people so we added a few dashes at the end and poured the soup over cornbread. Thank you for the awesome recipe!!
DrDan
Hi Heather,
Welcome to the blog.
Glad it worked so well for you.
Thanks for the note.
Dan
Amy
Just made this and it was amazing. I did add about 1/2 cup of left over mashed potatoes the last 30 minutes and it thickened up perfectly. Definitely making again.
Lynne
What do you prefer to use : Northern beans or Navy beans- and why ? Love to hear everyone’s responses as I am a new chef!
DrDan
Hi Lynne,
Welcome to the blog.
Old habits die hard and if using dry, I tend to grab Navy beans. If precooked, I tend to buy Great Northern.
The obvious difference is the size. Navy is a bit smaller and the Great Northern is slightly bigger and slightly firmer.
I think I prefer the Great Northern a bit due to size. But when cooking dry, the smaller Navy bean will cook a little faster and I’m sure it is done.
So no big preference for me.
Dan
Jonette
Used a honey baked ham bone, but the beans turned out too sweet. Any idea how to fix this?
DrDan
Hi Jonette,
Welcome to the blog.
Most of mine are honey baked for the “Honey Baked Ham Store”. A lot of running water to rinse off the sugar and if there is crust on it, take a knife to it. Some brands get the sugar down into the cuts on the meat and it will be hard to get them clean.
You are right, you need to get as much of the sugar gone as possible.
Dan
Ash the Homelyhappychef
Hi Dr.Dan I have a ham bone from my family easter, I had removed almost all the meat, as much as possible anyway lol. It is mainly bone with a little bit of meat and not much fat on it from what I can tell. This is my first time making this soup, I remember it fondly from my early childhood. Would it still work with just the bone and some meat added?
DrDan
Hi Ash,
You do need some “meat on the bone” so if you stripped it, you don’t have much to work with. You could try it by adding some ham from elsewhere like a slice of ham from the meat department. I’m not sure how well that would work. Or just wait until next time.
Melissa
I made this ham and bean soup for New Years Day. I made it with smoked ham hocks-it was absolutely fabulous. Super thick and tasty, effect for a winter day. I’m making it again tomorrow for my Community “Soup” Pot Luck. I’m sure it will be a major hit!! Thank you so much for such a GREAT recipe!! I’m now going to look at all of your other recipes as I believe they will be just as good.
DrDan
Hi Melissa,
It is one of my favorite soups.
Thanks for the note.
Dan
Deborah Watson
I made this soup tonight with a good, meaty hambone that had been frozen from our Christmas ham. Ample bone and about 1 lb of meat. Instead of using 2 crockpots, I cooked the soup on high instead of low and added the hambone after about 1.5 hours of cooking. Total cooking time was 5.5 hours. I also did not soak the beans but picked through them, rinsed them andded them straight away. The meat gave the broth a great flavor and it needed only a small amount of salt at the end. My last alteration was removing 1/3 of the beans and 2 cups of broth to a medium sized, deep container and using an immersion blender to puree it smooth to add thickness and body to the finished product without using cream/ milk and flour or cornstarch. This is a definite make again! Excellent comfort food! It was served with fresh, hot cornbread.
DrDan
Hi Deborah,
Thanks for sharing your experience. Your thickening method is probably the preferred. At this point, I don’t think corn starch is a good idea due to the trouble with reheating. Other options would be some potato flakes, tapioca or arrow root.
Thanks for the note.
Dan
Lynne
This soup is incredibly good. I soaked a pound of white peas to use and found 8 hrs on low to be perfect in my 6 qt. pot. It didn’t need any more spice and the smokey flavour from my spiral ham gave it the right touch. After it was done I added about a tbsp. of potatoe starch to thicken it up a bit. My husband raved about it and I will definately be making this version again….thank so much
Terry
Hi Doc, love your site. I’m making ham and bean soup as I type. My recipe is very similar except I use chicken broth instead of water (or 4 cps broth 2 cps water) and don’t soak the beans (I don’t get the gas). I also add a teaspoon of thyme and rosemary and about 1/8 cup of ketchup and a teaspoon of red wine vinegar. Give it a try. Like you say recipes are guidelines, and I’m always tweaking recipes to my liking. I also am impressed with your recipe calculator so much I made my own excel spreadsheet to mimic it, I bet many don’t know it’s even there. Thanks for that and having recipes for us that don’t have children at home anymore (retired folks).. and hate wasting food, nice. Wonderful job keep it up.
DrDan
Hi Terry,
Glad you are enjoying the site. It is a great hobby for me. I’m glad you saw the “guidelines” comment. That is something many people just don’t understand about recipes. But I try to make them complete enough as written for most people.
You soup modifications sound great but watch the salt.
Thanks for the note.
Dan
Aliceyn
Our “funny” family story… I was a young single mom, granddaughter of farmers, dating the son of San Francisco socialites. We were served a ham dinner during one of the holidays. (from the honey baked stores). I was helping clean the kitchen and GASPED when my future mother in law put the bone (with MOST of the meat) in the trash. She looked up and realized that as a single working mom barely able to feed my 2 children- what she had done. She said, “oh dear, I had heard you make soup from bones…do you want this?” That “bone” fed my children for a week, THEN I made the navy bean soup. 34 years later my husband still looks forward to ham bone soup. His mother is still shocked and possibly a little proud of all the things I can do and no one else they know can…
Jodie Knop
DrDan
Thank you for this recipe. I am making it today (with the vegetables) It looks like the soup my husband’s Grandmother Millie always made, without the vegetables. She never used a recipe. He has wanted me to make this for a long time. It is a bland soup, but she had always put a bottle of ketchup, bottle of hot sauce, chopped purple onions, and brown sugar on the table. We would add what we wanted to our bowl. Can’t wait to eat!
Michel
I’m making this one..after reading many recipes.! Going to add leftover mash yam (about one)..at the last hour of cooking time
DrDan
Hi Michel,
Good touch with the yam. It should thicken some and add taste.
Dan
Cathrine Livingston
I have made this soup twice in the past 5 days and followed the recipe as posted, except I used chicken stock instead of plain water in the crock pot. I did not have to add any seasoning at the end and the ham provided enough salt to the soup. I did mash some of the beans as suggested in the recipe. My husband said it was fantastic!! Will add this to my permanent recipe book.
DrDan
Hi Cathrine,
Glad you like it. I have a ham coming this weekend and I think my wife is more excited for the soup.
Dan
Trudy
I have been cooking for over 60 years. I have made all kinds of soups, cooking many meals teaches one a lot of things. One thing for sure, I no longer soak beans, it is a waste of time, leaches out the vitamins, and slows the cooking of a meal. The fastest, easiest, and most economical is to wash thoroghly, sorting if necessary, and placing in an appropriate size container e.g. Stainless Steel covered 2 quart or larger. Ratio of beans to water 1:2. 1 cup beans, 2 cups of clean, filtered water. Cook on HIGH for five minutes, let sit for an hour. The beans if cooked enough, when you draw out a teaspoon of cooked beans and blow on them will split and curl the shell. Never, ever add anything to the water, other than the beans. If the beans are old they will need more cooking time, and willnot split their shell when you blow on them. Then While all that was going on I was busy chopping the veggies. The onion, celery, carrots, and peeling fresh garlic to crush later into the soup. I saute the veggies in EVOO (Extra Virgin Olive Oil) or EV Coconut Oil. This brings out the flavor and seals in the vitamins in the vegetables. Here you can add precooked Acorn Squash, Sweet Potatoes, etc. Herbs of choice can go here as well. Potatoes added to the soup will serve as a thickener. Also, as the soup cooks, mash some of the Beans to thicken it as well with the back of a large spoon or a bean masher. This creates a smoother texture, besides thickening it. Add the sauteed veggies, cooked beans, meat (like Ham or even a smoked spicy summer sausage cutup); next, add the homemade soup stock, bay leaf, a little salt, black ground pepper. All these hints makes the soup quick, tasty, digestible, and easy to ladle up. I usually cook it on High four hours, and low for 4-6 hours. Your nose will tell you when it is ready. Add picante sauce, zucchini, kale, etc. if you wish to have more nutrious spicy, veggie soup. The length of cooking at 600 minutes is off-putting. Hours is more palatable. e.g. 6-10 hours
Donna
I love this soup! I think it has great flavor exactly as it is written. I was thinking of using this recipe as a basis for split pea soup. Do you think it would work with split peas?
DrDan
Hi Donna,
I have never made a split pea soup but it seems to me it would. I would need to investigate a number of other recipes to be sure but it makes a ham broth and seems to have about the right composition. I know mostly they use chicken broth but the ham would be better taste wise. I might be a great soup.
Dan
Sandra Cullen
Started this recipe & have a time lapse between ending the 8 hr soaking of dry beans & actual time I will prepare crockpot due to having to make trip to grocery for veggies. Do soaked beans need to be refrigerated while awaiting crockpot? Is it ok to substitute a can of celery soup instead of celery rib since hate to purchase whole big bunch when only need one or two individual ribs?
DrDan
Skip the celery if you want. Like all soups, use what you have. I like to refrigerate the beans during soaking although many don’t. I see a water nutrient mixture that bacteria can grow in.
Joann Colan
Rake through beans when they are DRY first before rinsing and cleaning with water. This way the beans won’t stick together when combing for rocks, dirt clods, rotten or broken beans with skins off. I rinse and scrub several times to make sure they are clean before I cook.
Gillian
Oh My!!! Made this soup today and boy was it delicious. As with every dish I usually make, I start with a basic recipe and make it my own but I always give credit where credit is due. So the only changes I made were to use homemade chicken stock, fresh thyme, fresh garlic and fresh parsley. I also added about a half cup to three quarter cup of finely diced butternut squash because I love it in most of my soups as a natural, slightly sweet, thickener. Plus its another sneaky veggie my kid wouldn’t eat otherwise. I threw in a couple diced potatoes at the end along with a tsp or so of seasoned salt. I’m very close to saying that this is now my absolute favorite bean soup. Thanks for sharing.
Pauly P in NC
Good think I like Celery in my soups!!
Are you sure there are to be TWO STALKS of celery as opposed to 2 RIBS?
I could not fit two stalks worth of celery in my 8 qt pot…I stopped at one stalk.
Admittedly, I did have a hefty ham bone, but….
Otherwise a wonderfully easy and delicious recipe…THANK YOU!!!
DrDan
Hi Pauly,
You caught me on the computer. We appear to have a terminology difference. When I grew up we called a rib of celery a stalk and what you call a stalk a bunch. I did a fast Google https://www.seattletimes.com/life/food-drink/celery-question-8212-whats-a-rib-vs-stalk/
I think I will keep my present terminology.
Have a good holiday season.
Dan
Mark
Ham bone is really cheap now. I might have to pick one up and give this one a try.
DrDan
Hi Mark,
Thanks for the note. I have a Honey Baked in the mail now for the weekend. So I’m doing this next week.
Dan
Marsha
Really good recipe! I followed your recipe and used the ingredients you suggested, using 4 carrots and 3 celery per my family’s taste. Took 8 hours on low, after soaking the beans for about 8 hours. I actually kept the beans covered in the refrigerator for a couple of days before I cooked the soup today and they came out the very right consistency. I had to add more seasoning at the end but did not add any salt to this soup. Thank you! I will be trying more 😀
Robert
My ex wife made very good bean soup using smoked turkey (I’m a heart patient) but she also made dumplings using Bisquick. She made her soup on the stove and added the dumplings just before serving. This also added some thinking to the soup. She also add carrots and onions.
DrDan
Hi Robert,
Thanks for the note. I can see it now…
Dan
Jane Montello
Made the bean soup and it turned out great. My mom (who has passed away and left no written instructions) used her leftover bean soup to make baked beans. I have been unable to find such a recipe on the internet. Do you have one? I am going to try to adapt various baked bean recipes using the leftover soup, but would love to get your take on it. Thank you. Your site is wonderful for cooking for 2.
DrDan
Hi Jane, Thanks for the note. I have not heard of doing that. It seems like the liquid to bean ratio would be off but you could drain some. I guess I would drain the liquid, call the ham as bacon. then add the ketchup/BBQ sauce, onion and other things. Honestly, I have not found a baked bean recipe I really like. I find most of them way too sweet for my taste. The best I have had is at Marlowe’s in Memphis but they don’t publish their recipe.
Dan
Jennifer Szalach
Delicious! My husband and I absolutely loved this recipe, we will definitely be making this again!
Tammy
This is very good. I will never throw out a ham bone again.
DrDan
Hi Tammy
I grew up never wasting anything so tossing the hambone is just wrong.
Thanks so much for the note.
Dan
Nancy
Great recipe and similar to my own. I add a couple of small potatoes to absorb some of the salt. A jalapeño pepper also adds some great flavor and and little heat. I like my soup a little thicker and creamier, so I take about a half cup of soup, add a little milk and cornstarch and blend it together and return to soup to finish cooking. No salt is ever needed.
Laura
This was an excellent base recipe. I made a few seasoning modifications to suit our tastes and used a few more carrots, celery and onion. Delicious. Thank you. I didn’t know where to start and this was perfect.
DrDan
Hi Laura,
Recipes are always just “guidelines” anyway. Great modifications.
Thanks for the note.
Dan
Shelia
this is close to the recipe I always use, but I add a can of tomatoes (and sometimes potato to thicken it some). I’m making this this weekend using my New Years Day hambone. Yum.
DrDan
Hi Shelia,
Thanks for the note. I have done this with the can of tomatoes and it adds a nice touch.
I think I need to keep some instant potatoes around for crockpot thickening emergencies.
Dan
Sarah
My crock pot isn’t large enough, how would I adapt it to the stovetop?
DrDan
I haven’t done a stovetop version for about 20 years so I’m not much help. I would say a stovetop version will probably cook much faster since low simmer on a stovetop is high plus a little in a crock pot. I would look at some other recipes.
Good luck,
Dan
Brittany
Wanted to give this 5/5 rating, could not find the place to eye it! Excellent recipe!
DrDan
Thanks Brittany,
The rating is by clicking a star in the recipe card area.
Dan
Susan Downey
Hi!
I found your recipe yesterday when I looked up recipes for ham and navy beans soups. I used a smoked pork hock and added 1 TBSP hand crushed Newfoundland Savory to the recipe.
It turned out Awesome! Not too salty and it had a great balance of flavours. I did not need to add any extra water as I have a crock pot with a lock down lid.
My husband enjoyed every bite!
DrDan
Hi Susan,
This is one of those recipes that just works and adapts to individual taste changes.
Thanks for the note.
Dan
Jennifer
On the soak or not-to-soak issue.
Soaking reduces the phytic acid content of the beans. Phytic acid is not denatured by cooking, only by water soak. I always soak oats and beans for this reason. You can look up the problems caused by too much phytic acid – but here is my personal story. We had oats (unsoaked) for breakfast almost every morning to save money one year. My otherwise healthy children (no sodas, no sugar in the house, very health conscious family) had 5 cavities and a ton of precavities by the end of the year. I figured out it was the oatmeal. Or rather, the phytic acid in the oatmeal. We stopped eating it so often, and when we do, I soak it overnight or use it in refrigerator oats with yogurt. My children have had zero cavities in the 4 years since that.
DrDan
The doctor in me says that you had calcium issues due to a large amount of chronic phytic acid intake. The occasional intake would not be much of an issue, but the ongoing phosphorous intake could well be the cause of a lot of calcium issues. You did excellent in figuring that one out. I have read more recipes recently suggesting not to soak but still I would. The old ways are the best ways some times.
Thanks for the note and reminding me of biochemistry from 40 yrs ago.
DrDan
Erica
Can’t figure out why you would rinse off any honey coating or spices. The sweetness makes ham and bean soup good.
DrDan
To me, there is way too much sugar on many hams and anything you can do to get the salt decreased here is a good thing.
Dan
Goose
Here’s my take: We like BIG beans in our soups, so I used a pound of dried Limas in your recipe. However, by the time that all the ham cooks off the bones (and I used TWO), much of those original dry beans cook down into gravy, so I add a can or two of prepared Great Northerns at the end. I also left out the carrots this time.
Also, by the time the soup has finished, I have added nearly double the cups of liquid, as it cooks down and concentrates. I started with 4 cups water and 1 cup chicken broth, and probably ended up with 4 cups of each, for a nicely savory and concentrated soup.
I pack the extra finished soup into freezer cartons, as there are just the two of us (as the blog is so titled!), so we can enjoy it later. What soup I keep fresh, and what I thaw out later, will be cut with more chicken broth (or perhaps vegetable broth … to avoid losing that great ham flavor!) and perhaps another can of prepared beans, as needed, since the finished soup is well-concentrated.
I agree with you that salt must be added exceedingly sparingly, only as required … and I did end up adding it again and again … as it was bland at first, as you mentioned … right up until the end. The salt was added only ¼ tsp at a time. I used both large crystal kosher-type salt, and also Lawry’s Seasoned Salt. This really did the trick, without wildly missing the mark, and going overly salty.
I also added Liquid Smoke, ⅛ tsp at a time, until the combination of the added salt and Liquid Smoke began to make the near-finished soup savory. I perhaps ended up using ½ tsp total. But, work up to it! The dry beans being cooked down into gravy also adds to the soup’s savory-ness.
Based on my result, I give your recipe a solid 5 out of 5! But, one’s got to have the patience to cook down those ham bones and those dry beans, sparingly adding flavor along the way! Mine easily cooked for 10 hours, and probably more than 12, until the ham was cooked completely off the bone.
DrDan
Hi Goose
Thanks for the comments. As you well know, recipes are just “guidelines” and should be modified according to taste and things like ham bones. Your hard work has paid off with a ton of great soup.
And thanks for the rating.
Dan
Hope
Does cooking it on high make a difference? I didn’t have 10 hours to wait only 8. It’s on hour 5 right now
DrDan
I suspect high is ok for a shorter time of course. Make sure the beans are done.
DrDan
Hope
My soup is turning out very watery. Any advice?
DrDan
Hi Hope,
You’re right this can be a bit watery so here are some options. 1) less water…. A lot of recipes use 10 cups and I only do 6. Plus you need to cover the ham mostly. 2) More beans… A fairly good solution and use a potato masher a little near the end of cooking…Just a little. 3) add potatoes diced at the beginning as one other commenter suggests. The starch will help thick some. 4) Along the same line as #3 add some mashed potato flacks near the end. 5) something like tapioca can be used.
Notice I did not include flour. I have never had any luck thicken in a crock pot with flour even when cooked on high. Flour needs a higher temp to thicken and I believe none of my three crock pots run that hot. I will say that arrowroot and cornstarch are not my favorite choices above because on reheating they do not do very well.
So numbers 2,3 or 4
DrDan
Shelia
try instant potato flakes.
Keith C
Just made recipie as is but also added some fresh oregano I had lying around. Fantastic! Finally a great outlet for all that left over ham!
Leslie
Followed your recipe, only I used pinto beans (that’s all I had at home), tasted great and not bland. Thankyou
Leslie
I plan on making your lunch lady rolls in my new kitchen aid mixer and this soup, however the only dried bean I have is pinto, can I use them is this recipe? Thank you
DrDan
I believe pinto will be similar to the navy beans but I’m not positive.
Dan
Pauk
I already knew how to make this soup but I did not have a hambone planning of him though so I came here looking for ideas on how to thicken it up one of the other people left the comment that they took some of the ham and beans and put in a blender to help thicken it that is a good idea
Marion
Bean soup is one of my favorites! To use smoked turkey necks in a crock pot,if I mix all the ingredients at the start, will the turkey necks get done when the rest of the soup does ?
DrDan
Since I have never seen or hear of a “smoked turkey neck” I will guess. Almost anything will be cooked by 8-10 hours in a crock pot. I assume they are smoked to preserve them so they are not raw meat but even raw turkey should be cooked in the 8-10 hours.
How is that for an uninformed answer?
If you do it, come back and report.
DrDan
RossC
Just made slow cooker navy beans w/ham hock last week, pretty much the same as your recipe..
Navy beans and ham hock was a staple growing up in our family.. My grandmother made a big batch on the stove top once a week.. I too make it in the slow cooker now-a-days and its pretty close to hers..
When I was a kid (back in the 40’s) my grandfather taught me to mash the beans and ham together and add a splash of ketchup and mix it all together… Still do it to this day and my wife still rolls her eyes when I do so…
DrDan
You know if my wife saw me do that she would slap me up not just roll the eyes. I loved ham soup as a child. I think I even asked for it for my birthday once. In this recipe I even did the dried beans but I don’t find any rocks in them like old times.
Again thanks for the note and rating
Dan
Cherie
What size crock pot would you recommend? I have a 5 quarter crock and I don’t think I could have fit all of this in it.
DrDan
At least 6 qt due to the ham size.
Dan
Maxine G
I followed your recipe but added a can of stewed tomatoes The seasoning in the tomatoes gives the soup a nice flavor. I also put a few cups of the cooked soup in the blender and added it back into the crockpot to thicken it up a bit and give it a nice consistency. Great recipe and so easy to use the crock pot!
Monica
Wonderful recipe! Thanks!
Ida
My husbands beloved Aunt always made great ham and bean soup. This is my second try and it looks delicious. My question is can I add potatoes to this or will it ruin it? I am making it tomorrow. Thank you!
DrDan
The potato should be fine. Put it in with the carrots. I think two medium diced would be about right but just guessing there.
DrDan
Barry
The recipe is great with onion, celery, and carrots. One more thing my mother always put in
was diced potatoes.
Theresa
Do you set the crock pot on low price high?
Theresa
Sorry, I meant low OR high.
DrDan
Low and I just edited to make it more apparent. Thanks for the note.
Dan
Joan Holschuh
Ina, I have never made ham an bean soup before. I have this great ham bone an decided to look at you site for a recipe. My husband’s mom always made soup with the ham bone an he thought it was a great idea. I will try it in the next day or two. Thanks Joan
Carole Milligan
My husband asked me to make ham bone and bean soup today. I found this post for your recipe, and it looks like an ideal recipe for the crockpot. I’ll add spices at the end, as you and others suggest. Thanks!
Carole Milligan
I made this yesterday, and it turned out very well. At the end, I added garlic powder and fresh ground pepper, as well as more ham. Delicious! Thank you for this easy recipe.
Gigi Schultz
Dr. Dan
I’ve made a similar soup like this ages ago and couldn’t remember the ingredients. Thank you for reminding me! This soup is simple and wonderful. For a little more flavor I add about a cup of V8-juice or tomato juice and a shake or two of Tabasco sauce at about the 8th hour of cooking. Now on to my fabulous ham bone I have thawing on the counter next to my soaking beans and ready to get cooking!
Dawn
Made this today! I’ve never made a bean soup like this before. It only took me 8 total hours to cook. It really needs to be seasoned at the end. I added garlic, salt, pepper, and Cayenne Pepper. Very good!
DrDan
Hi Dawn,
Yep this is a bland soup and seasoning to taste at the end is a good idea. The salt especially should wait to the end since many ham’s have lots of salt already.
Thanks for the note.
DrDan
Dustin
Dr. Dan,
Just finished prepping this recipe. It is now cooking on low in the crockpot. In substitution of the six cups of water, I used the four cups of remaining juices that cooked off the spiral ham I cooked two days ago for Thanksgiving. Then I added another four cups of water. Looking forward to trying this rendition of a childhood favorite with the added carrots, celery, and onion. Will let you know how it turns out.
DrDan
Given those choice… none would be my choice. Don’t add any sugar of any type. And ham usually has too much salt to begin with. None of the other spices or veggies do much for me.
Hopefully you have some pepper. It will be nice without the veggies and other spices. If you like spicy then a pinch of the crushed red pepper since it is a bit bland anyways.
DrDan
Naya
I need some help with spics to put in my great northern beans. The only veggies I have are cucumbers and green bell peppers. I have two of each. The spices I have are Cajun seasoning, kosher salt, table salt, sugar, paprika, oregano leaf, crushed red pepper, smoked paprika, ground cumin, tarragon leaves, thyme leaves, and chili powder. I usually use brown sugar but was not able to get it this time around. Please help as soon as you are able. Thank you so much. I appreciate it.
Lorrie
Great recipe, I add smoked ham hocks and the ham bone. My mom always used the smoked ham hocks.
Elane
Hi Dr. Dan,
Just found your site while I was looking for a healthier carrot cake. So I have been scrolling through your recipes and admiring your wonderful dogs. I saw this recipe and I thought I would let you know that I like using smoked turkey parts to make the soup when a ham bone is unavailable. It works out great! Oh yeah, can’t wait to try your carrot cake!!! I like your site, thank you and love your dogs.
plantcrone
Great take on the typical “Senate Bean Soup” that my mom and grand mother made. I liked the emphasis on low sodium and, like the author, have decided to use dried beans rather than more expensive (and highly processed) canned beans.
I used several healthy twists of ground black pepper, a tsp of chili pepper flakes and a shake of hot chili powder to spice it up a bit..I thought it was a tad too bland for my spice loving family.
I’d always used chicken or vegetable broth in my ham bone soup before but this time I let the ham bone and ham do the flavoring of the 6 C of water and didn’t notice the difference.
Appreciate your easy crock pot version of this American Staple.
DrDan
Thanks for the note. It is a bit bland like most ham/bean soups so your additions are a good idea if you want a little more spice. To me, that bland ham and bean taste is childhood…
In one of my previous ham bone soups, a commenter suggested that the broth was not needed. I now agree.
Again thanks for the comment and rating.
DrDan