Fresh strawberry pie is a wonderful summer treat. A simple killer recipe everybody will love. Plus almost any fool including me can pull this off. Make two for the party or family.
Publisher’s note: This recipe was originally published June 23, 2012. I have re-edited the photos and text. Have a slice of pie on me from one of our favorite recipes.
I have no inspiration recipe to refer to since we have used this recipe for over 40 years. It was a tightly guarded recipe in my wife’s family. The “secret” Big Boy strawberry pie recipe. But of course, it is not that secret.
There are many variations sprinkled around the net. Some add the jello and then thicken, some mix the sugar and cornstarch first and add boiling water but it still needs to be cooked more to thicken… umm ok.
The volume of glaze varies some from recipe to recipe. Our volume is right. We have done this well over a hundred times. The other variations don’t matter.
My Rating
The easiest rating of the year. I can live on this and will try sometime soon.
Pro Tips: Recipe notes for Strawberry Pie
The Pie Crust
I have done pie crusts from scratch, and nothing beats a homemade pie crust, but it is a fair amount of work for me. The main features of this pie are the strawberries and the glaze. That is what you will focus on and not the crust.
I used the refrigerated Pillsbury crust which I find quite acceptable. Get your crust any way you want; homemade, Pillsbury refrigerated, or one of those frozen jobs ( I have never had one of those).
The Strawberries
Next, some people put the large strawberries in the crust and then pour the glaze over them. I make a mess when I do it that way, and some strawberries end up not covered.
Cut them up a little to make bite size and mix into the glaze. It works better and is easier to eat. Be sure the glaze cools before adding the berries; we don’t want to cook them.
The Glaze
We are making the glaze. You can can buy packages of glaze. Please don’t do that. It is almost tasteless. Do not use sugar-free jello and please use Jello brand.
Final Notes
Third, you may notice some variation in the pictures. This is two cookings so the crust and saucepan may look different from picture to picture.
Lastly, this is great the first day and second day. By the third day, the berries deteriorate some.
Other Summer Favorites
Other Pie Suggestions
Simple ingredients. Get the best looking ripe strawberries you can.
Start with a pre-baked pie crust. I did a Pillsbury refrigerated one. Just follow the instructions on the package.
Clean and slice up one pound of strawberries. Set them aside and let them air dry while you make the glaze. It seems to stick better to dryer berries.
In a larger saucepan, add 1 cup Sugar to 1 1/2 cups Water over medium heat. Sprinkle in 1/4 cup Cornstarch slowly while stirring.
The mixture will turn cloudy. Stir continuously over medium heat, and in 4-5 minutes it will turn clear and thicken. When the thickening is complete (about 30 seconds after it started to clear) remove from heat. Add 3oz package of Strawberry Jello to the mixture and stir completely dissolved.
Allow the mixture to cool to room temperature (about 30 minutes). The stir in the berries.
Add the berry mixture to the pie crust.
Refrigerate for at least 2 hours (3 plus is better) before cutting. Keep refrigerated between servings. This is great the first day and second day. By the third day, the berries deteriorate some.
Do you want more recipes from 101 Cooking for Two? Sign up for the newsletter and get all posts delivered straight to your inbox!
Easy Fresh Strawberry Pie
Ingredients
- 1 pie crust - I used Pillsbury
- 1 pound strawberries
- 3 oz strawberry jello - one package
- 1/4 cup corn starch
- 1 cup sugar
- 1 1/2 cup water
Instructions
- Start with a pre-baked pie crust. I did a Pillsbury refrigerated one. Just follow the instructions on the package.
- Clean and slice up one pound of strawberries. Set them aside and let them air dry while you make the glaze.
- In a larger sauce pan, add 1 cup sugar to 1 1/2 cups water over medium heat. Sprinkle in 1/4 cup cornstarch slowly while stirring. The mixture will turn cloudy. Stir continuously over medium heat and in 4-5 minutes it will turn clear and thicken. When the thickening is complete (about 30 seconds after it started to clear) remove from heat.
- Add 3oz package of Strawberry Jello to the mixture and stir completely dissolved. Allow the mixture to cool to room temperature (about 30 minutes).
- The stir in the berries. Add the berry mixture to the pie crust.
- Refrigerate for at least 2 hours (3 plus is better) before cutting. Keep refrigerated between servings. This is great the first day and second day. By the third day, the berries deteriorate some.
Recipe Notes
Pro Tips:
- You can make your own pie crusts, but the frozen or refrigerated versions are fine for this pie. 9 inch is just right.
- Pick nice ripe strawberries.
- You can buy glaze but please make your own. It is easy and tastes so much better.
- Some people like to do whole berries with the point up. All for looks. Please cut them into bite-size pieces, it is so much easier to eat.
- Good for 2 days in the refrigerator but not too good the third day. Will not freeze well.
- Make two at once; the work is about the same for double the reward. I love it for breakfast.
Check Out Other Great Recipes
Nutrition is generally for one serving. Number of servings is stated above and is my estimate of normal serving size for this recipe.
All nutritional information are estimates and may vary from your actual results. This is home cooking, and there are many variables. To taste ingredients such as salt will be my estimate of the average used.
Originally Published June 23, 2012
S
Didn’t find any question about pie plate size. 9”? 10”? Makes a difference with amount of ingredients!
Dan Mikesell AKA DrDan
The standard 9 inch is fine. The frozen 8 inch is a bit small. I haven’t seen a 10 inch one for years but it would be about 20% more volume. So you could increase ingredients by 20% or just make it a bit thinner.
I added some wording in the notes.
Dan
gayle
Excellent with two modifications. I used 3 T cornstarch and whisked that together with the sugar before adding to the water. I used cookingwithk homemade butter shortbread pie crust and this was superb combination.
I wish good intentioned people would make it before they comment.
Martha Worley
Well, this city has no strawberry jello! Maybe everyone is making your strawberry pie for Easter! I got jello brand strawberry-banana because that’s what they had! So what if it has a little banana flavor!! (Hmmm, guess I could stick a few banana slices in it!)
Happy Easter to Dr Dan & family.
Dan Mikesell AKA DrDan
Hi Martha,
I think the banana will be ok although I have never had to resort to that. We do love our strawberry pie.
Thanks for the note and rating. Have a good holiday.
Dan
colleen
I have this pie several times and it is always good. Also I have used it with peach jello and fresh peaches and it is awesome. My question is can you freeze jello based pie?
DrDan
Hi Colleen,
I love the peach idea. I will try that.
Freezing not recommended. The jello will loose it’s texture and be somewhat disgusting and the fruit will also thaw with a frozen fruit texture.
Dan
Dori S.
This pie was so easy and delicious, everyone loved it. I really appreciate the detailed instructions and tips. Followed the recipe as written, using a store bought crust. It was a good tip to dry the berries a little…will be making this again. Thank you for posting.
Christine Koenig
I just buy the glaze! It’s all ready, no mess, no fuss and it tastes great! Yes, I do use Pillsbury Pie crusts, as shown in the picture! 😋 it all comes together in a blink of an eye, well almost…😉
Lisa
I always used to buy the premade glaze too. Then one day, I ate a strawberry pie slice that was made with strawberry jello like this recipe. Oh my goodness! The homemade glaze had so much more strawberry flavor than the store bought glaze! I highly recommend trying it.
DrDan
Hi Lisa,
I so agree with you, I think this is so much better then the pre-made I have tried in the past. There may be some variation but this is always good.
Thanks for the note.
Dan
Robin McCown
I’ve made this for years. I recall my mom making it at least 20 years ago. Where did you get the recipe?
DrDan
Handed down through my wife’s family. They “stole it” from a family friend probably 60 yrs ago. It’s a long story. But there are similar ones on the internet.
Leslie
I love this strawberry pie, great recipe I plan to use often!. I have not been receiving your new blog updates for about 4 weeks. Do I need to sign up again? Thank you Leslie
DrDan
We do love our strawberry Pie… I need to do one soon. Go ahead and sign up again… if the signup widget shows up… I have a war between the ads and the widgets this weekend and tech support is not available until Monday. Yagou might want to wait until Tuesday. A major change in format of the site is coming soon and we will see if I can break even more things.
Dan
Krystal Shearer
Oops, by teaspoons*, just a little cold water as necessary (for anybody else who could possibly have the strange troubles that I have in the kitchen. Bah!)
Krystal Shearer
I got it to work!!! I’d never used cornstarch in a recipe before so I had to Google around a bit as well :) I used 1/4 cup cornstarch and then I added cold water to it by tablespoons until it wasn’t oobleck anymore, then added THAT to the sugar water. Worked like a charm. Possibly I should have cut down on the content of water in the pan in the first place, as it was replaced, but that’s okay – we’ll see if it sets up correctly. Thanks for the recipe! :)
Dr Dan
It hasn’t been a problem for me. Corn starch needs to be powder and if it is in lumps, maybe it has got moisture in it in the past and you need new???? Otherwise, I just keep sturring while I slowly add the corn starch. If a glob goes in, smash it against the side and keep sturring. Another option I have seen in other recipes is to mix the corn starch with the sugar first. Give that a try…
Krystal Shearer
I had an awful time making the cornstarch break apart in the water/sugar – first step!!! I tried just stirring, I whisked it, I tried breaking them apart….how did it get like this? It’s so strange. It’s just like gloppy water/sugar with corn starch chunks everywhere. Sad day :(
Linda
I always add the sugar and cornstarch together mix well and then slowly add the water while stirring. Works every time
Chris
This makes me want to get some Plant City strawberries, great pie.